Montello WI Real Estate & Homes for Sale

WELCOME TO THE LAKE! Your opportunity to own on this amazing 5000 acre fishing/ boating lake in the heart of South Central Wisconsin. The home has the charm of yesteryear with original maple flooring and cabinetry in the kitchen. The bright living area features great wide water views and has updated flooring, lighting and paint. Baths have new fixtures and flooring and completely updated down to the studs. Heating/cooling efficent.. Mechanical improvements include new forced air heating/ central air cooling and water filtration system systems with other recent updates of drilled well, holding tank, electrical, sump pump w/ battery backup, siding and windows. The shoreline has professionally installed rip-rap. A wonderful year round lakefront retreat for the whole family.

Cute, Cozy and ready for you to call Home. This 2 story home sits in the City of Montello with easy access to everything town has to offer. Main floor bedroom with two additional bedrooms upstairs. Large laundry and mud room on main level and an unfinished basement for all your storage needs. Kitchen and Bathroom remodel is already done for you. Hardwood floors helps the past meet the present. Adorable covered porch for your morning coffee and a glass/screen house for outdoor entertaining. 2 car detached garage and a concrete pad for extra parking with a basketball hoop. Access to garage and drive are on Central Ave (all measurements are approx)

Open House Sat 4/13 11-1! The LAKE LIFE you?ve longed for! Move right into this year round beautiful waterfront ranch! Wall of windows overlooks your 62ft of pristine waterfront on 5013 acre Lake Puckaway! This 2 bdrm, 3 bath, 2154 sqft beauty has a touch of an "up north" cabin feel yet modern amenities, stone gas frplc & wide open flrplan-big kitchen island to entertain at! Relax on the big wraparound deck! Entertain in walkout LL fmly rm w/screened porch &hot tub! Add egress window in LL den to make 3rd bdrm! 1/2 acre lot offers towering trees for added privacy, 2 firepits, shed & massive 3 car gar perfect for your summer & winter toys + you can build an additional outbuilding! Bring your boats, UTVs & snowmobiles! Your pier w/boat lift &topper await! Furniture Avl! VRP $449,900-$469,900

Enjoy country living close to town!! You snooze you lose with this chance. Beautifully maintained 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home with a huge kitchen fit for a chef. The large open floor plan offers plenty of room for whatever your heart desires with 2 large living rooms. A new hot water heater, new dishwasher, and new blinds were installed 2024. If the attached garage isn't enough. The huge second garage with a wood burner is sure to have plenty of room for all your toys. This slice of heaven even has its own apple orchard, rhubarb, asparagus beds and even room for more gardens. Sit back and enjoy the views of the wildlife. Just minutes away John Muir Park and many other fishing and hunting opportunities. Schedule a showing today!

A unique opportunity to own on this great 2200 acre fishing and boating lake, several thousand feet of finished living space, several hundred feet of lakeshore on an acre of land, complete with your own boat landing. Turn this historic restaurant into your own personal family gathering property, endless potential with over 8000 sq ft of living space. Property boasts a huge living area with great views overlooking the lake. A commercial kitchen any chef would love. A beautiful horseshoe bar for entertaining. Partition off the living area and continue to use or lease the historic bar/restaurant for income generating potential. A gentle slope to water's edge offers a boat landing and place for multiple piers. An amazing property with potential for a myriad of uses.

Spacious 5-bedroom home offers 120ft of frontage on Lake Puckaway. Enjoy the view of the lake from the deck, providing the perfect backdrop for your relaxation and entertainment. Cozy up by the free-standing wood stove in the living room. With newer flooring and roof this home is move-in ready and designed for easy living with 4.5 acres to enjoy. The attached 2-car garage and additional 30 x 40 pole building offer ample storage space for your toys and equipment to explore all the hunting fishing and watersports Lake Puckaway has to offer. Don't miss out on the opportunity to own a property with waterfront views!

Everything is BETTER at the LAKE! Beautiful "like new" waterfront home on Buffalo Lake in Montello. With views from every room, this 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath, home is sure to please. This home offers; open concept design, first floor primary bedroom with attached bath/closet, A/C unit (Ductless Mini-split), 2 car attached garage, finished walkout LL with 2 bedrooms, full bath, laundry room, and family room. Enjoy nature outside by the fire pit or on the pier, or entertain inside by the cozy wood burning fireplace! This lake offers great fishing and an abundance of wildlife!

Get ready for a summer of fun in the sun! Own your own condo just off of the shores of of Lake Puckaway. Wildlife galore! Outstanding fishing including state record Northern Pike! 2 Bed, 1 Bath - nice open floor plan. New pier & an included boat slip. Heated inground pool! Restaurant within walking distance. Condo is currently enrolled in the association's optional rental program. Super easy to rent it out while you aren't using it - the association handles everything for you! Less than an hour from Wisconsin Dells! Condo could be used year round but the water is off from Oct 15 - April 1st. Condo fees of $2,500 due yearly in April.

This stately 1904 house sits on what was known at the time as Society Hill in Montello, WI. It's waiting for you to provide the time and attention necessary to bring it back to life. The 2,600 square foot house sits on a massive .51 acre double lot and has 5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The original section of the home retains most of its original hardwood floors. Since 2021, the electrical service has been upgraded to 200 amps and a new radiant hydronic heating system with an indirect water heater tank has been installed. The most expensive upgrades have been taken care of, and this house is ready to finish to fit your vision.

Here's the getaway property you've been waiting for! Enjoy 150 feet of frontage on Lake Puckaway, and don't forget your water skis! Single Wide Manufactured home is well maintained, and boasts two living areas, as well as 3 bright bedrooms, two full bathrooms AND a den (currently being used as a bedroom). Large kitchen w/ island is perfect for entertaining and has ample storage. All this with conveniences such as washer, dryer, central air and 2 car detached garage! Lot is level for so many uses, and is over an acre. Check out the 3D tour!

Year round living can be enjoyed in this stand alone log home as part of the Oak Ridge Condo Assn on Buffalo Lake. 2 bdrms / 1 bath offering a nice size open concept living, dining and kitchen area. Large deck for outdoor entertaining. Condo Assn offers 400' of water frontage with 4 piers and 1/8 interest in 6 acres of green space. This unit as been well maintained with many updates. Private septic with a shared well that is maintained by the Assn. Act now for your summer time enjoyment with friends and family!

Condo - Year round living can be enjoyed in this stand alone log home as part of the Oak Ridge Condo Assn on Buffalo Lake. 2 bdrms / 1 bath offering a nice size open concept living, dining and kitchen area. Large deck for outdoor entertaining. Condo Assn offers 400' of water frontage with 4 piers and 1/8 interest in 6 acres of green space. This unit as been well maintained with many updates. Private septic with a shared well that is maintained by the Assn. Act now for your summer time enjoyment with friends and family!

You won?t want to miss out on your chance to own such a unique property! This open concept ranch home has four bedrooms, two full bathrooms, sits on 3.3 acres and offers 151 feet of water frontage! Enjoy the GORGEOUS Buffalo Lake views while entertaining on the deck or the lower walkout patio. There is plenty of outdoor storage and space in the 24x26 detached garage and a 24x48 shed that was built in 2023 for all your hobbies and toys! The fireplace adds the perfect touch of cozy to the living room and big windows provide a perfect view of the property and lake. The basement is nothing short of amazing as it includes a large living space, second kitchen, spacious bedroom and Rec Room with a pool table! Basement carpet was replaced in 2022. Make this house your home before Spring hits!

Come check out this immaculate full time or weekend getaway home just a stone's throw from Lake Puckaway. This Single Wide mobile home has a large stick built addition with wood burner & large windows. This 2 bedroom, 1 bath, home has newer windows, central air, all appliances are included. Private well and holding tank. Large 2 car detached garage with heat & air conditioning, extra cedar room that also has heat & air, plus a bonus special room. There is a new metal roof on the garage & cedar room. With a large metal roof gazebo on the patio for all of your entertaining. There is an extra 30X40 Cleary shed for all of your toys since you are right on the ATV/UTV & snowmobile trails. Close to restaurants, 1 mile to boat launch.

Welcome to easy living! Seller is offering a $2300 closing credit. Located just between Portage and Montello on the Fox river is this completely remodeled 2-bedroom 2 bathroom manufactured home. The insulated windows will keep your heating costs down this winter! A spacious storage shed along with 2 decks help occupy the outside. An incredible view of the Fox River out of the master bedroom windows is one you won't want to miss! Motivated seller! Lot rent is $350/month and includes water, sewer, snow removal, and garbage. Pets are allowed at an extra cost per month. No renters or rent to own. Ask me about the easy financing options available!

AMAZING WIDE-WATER LAKEFRONT VIEWS. 2 bedroom, 1 bath updated Single Wide mobile home. Huge 3 season porch offers a great spot for relaxing while overlooking the lake. Bright and clean with interior updates, this property offers an affordable opportunity to own on this spectacular 2200 acre fishing and boating lake. A great place to spend the summer, the shaded lot has landscaped, rip-rapped shoreline. Don't wait, this property at a great price will not last long.

Relax in this charming 2-bedroom home overlooking Buffalo Lake. The home sits atop a hill with great views of the lake from the deck or from the large windows facing the water. Enjoy the cool fall evenings by the fireplace. The walls and ceiling are constructed of solid pine boards for that cabin feel. Outside you will find a garage with an additional full bath for guests, a dog bath, or just a convenient place to clean up after working in the yard. Newer storage shed and extra parking area provides plenty of room for your storage needs. 85 feet of waterfrontage provides access to 2179 acres of Buffalo Lake, with great panfish and bass fishing. Ride your UTV/ATV to town right from your property too!

World-Class estate for sale in Marquette County, WI outside of Princeton. This peaceful grace of country living embodies 303.5+/- acres of sheer bliss. Americana farmhouse with 4-beds and 1-bath with room to garden. Additionally, a secluded 1-bed, 1-bath Cabin on the banks of the Mecan River. Property serves as hunting camp, vacation rental or weekend getaway. (2) dwellings on each side of the road. There?s 52+/- acres of row crop, 1.5-mile of frontage on the Mecan River and a mix of timberland and lowlands home to trophy whitetail, waterfowl and pheasants. The estate has been family-owned for over a whopping 5-decades. Own a piece of America?s finest asset. Portion enrolled in WRP. Property can be split. 2 hours from Milwaukee. 15 minutes to historic Green Lake.

Farmhouse with land for sale in Marquette County, WI just minutes from historic Princeton! Peaceful grace of country living embodies 92+/- acres. Excellent permanent residence, getaway/hunting retreat or vacation rental. 2-hours from Milwaukee, 15 minutes from the cultural and resort town of Green lake. Restored mid 1900?s farmhouse features a 4-bed, 1-bath setup with a new addition bump-out. Ornate craftsmanship signifies the hardworking agrarian pride of country living. Enlighten those chasing the American Spirit of county living. Raise a garden, enjoy a pond out back and fish from the Mecan River. Offers deer, turkey and pheasant hunting. Great fishing! 28+/- acres of row crop. Family-owned for 56 years. Massive barn with several farm sheds. Own a piece of America?s finest asset. Additi

Secluded Cabin with water frontage for sale in Marquette County, WI minutes from historic Princeton! Enchanting fairytale of 97 acres charmed by over 4,200ft of crystal-clear Mecan river frontage! 15 minutes from cultural and resort town of Green Lake. Serves as hunting camp, vacation rental or weekend getaway. Nestled in the heart of trophy class whitetail, pheasant lands, waterfowl flyways and trout waters. Family owned for over 5-decades. 1-bed, 1-bath cabin on the banks of the Mecan River. Loft provides ample room for guests. Drilled 6-inch well, holding tank, electricity as well a telephone line. Baseboard and Vermont Castings wood stove provides heat. Half wraparound porch with views. 24+/- acres of row crop. Portion of land enrolled in WRP. Whooping Cranes and migration flyway.

Attention new price and additional updates! Move in condition Montello Home ready for new owners. This three bedroom two bathroom home has brand new deck, updated appliances, new roof and skylights, and many more updates to long to list. Tall basement with new interior staircase has plenty of space for storage or extra living space. Quiet street just minutes from downtown Montello and the school with a country feel. Call today for your private showing.

TWO HOMES + country living! Live in one and use the other as a rental or set up your own small business! Main level of "Main Home" features an open Kitchen/Dining area, full bath, large Living Room and primary bedroom and a 2nd Bedroom. Basement features a Rec room (pool table included), bar, custom built card playing area, and 2 additional Bedrooms. Laundry currently located downstairs, but there are hookups on main floor. 27? above ground pool and pool deck. Commercial building (#3286) is 1,500 SF (LR 30x11, Kit 21x16, B1 16x11, B2 16x12, B3 11x9 Bath 11x8). 3 Bedrooms, 1 Bathroom, Ranch Style w/ Central Air. .34 Acres zoned Residential .26 Acres zoned Commercial

Beautiful 3 bed, 2 bath home on Lake Emery, move in condition, many updates, furnace and water heater 2015, open concept with vaulted & wood beam ceilings, all furnishings and most flooring are new. Master bedroom full bath with walk in closet. Great fishing Lake, close to I39. Seller is leaving just about everything, even the front porch swing! Seller has never used the water softener or the wood stove. This is a no wake lake.

Welcome to 5000 acre Lake Puckaway: This immaculate 2 bedroom, Single Wide, mobile home offers an affordable way to get on to this amazing fishing, boating lake. Exceptional views from both the kitchen/ living area of the home, this property has been well maintained, evident from the time you enter the home. Updates include the flooring and new 2000 gallon holding tank in 2022. 2 good sized bedrooms, both with spacious closets and built in dressers. 18' x 22' 3 season area offers enjoyment when the weather is not cooperative and provides added storage for your kayaks and canoes. Gently sloping lot to water's edge. Owned by the same family for 50 years, it is time for new owners to begin making memories.

***PRICE REDUCED*** Montello - Not far from schools on beautiful lot. Beautiful rear yard with lots of room for kids and landscaping. Features attractive 2 BR ranch style home w/full kitchen - pantry and dinette. Nice living room with large picture window. Open floor plan makes easy flow of interior. 2 bedrooms with closets and new carpet. Energy efficient natural gas furnace and central air conditioning. Utility room and possible half bath. This area could be a workshop with possible plumbing hook-up. Home is about 750 Sq Ft from outside measurements. 12x20 ft. garage. Also storage shed to far rear of property. Vinyl and wood siding.